2015-11-15
XKCD Isn't Funny - #1587 - Food Rule
My food rule is no meat that breathes air but I'm allowed to get the General's Chicken Combo (D24) at Chinese places because it's really just MSG.
This is one of those comics that would be vastly improved if we just knew why it was happening. I get that it's a play on the 'don't eat anything with a face' rule, but it falls flat without any context.
The lack of context also makes it hard to tell if the "ew, food I don't recognize!" vibe is intentional or not. It's easy for me to read this comic like the person's choosing that rule so they don't have to eat things they haven't seen before. But because this is a presentation to the reader, floating in the void, I don't really know if that interpretation is right or not.
Instead of saying it directly to the reader, the comic should be a series of panels. One stickman would tell another stickman why he chose this diet, kinda like how one guy tells the other about The Martian in #1536.
Also, shouldn't oysters and shrimp both be in one 'shellfish' category?
Labels:
criticism,
execution issues,
greg,
xkcd,
xkcd isn't funny
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment